Covered Calls: The Investor’s Dilemma—More Income or More Upside?
Generate steady cash flow, but don’t ignore the hidden risks
A Simple Strategy with a Catch
Every investor wants more income, but at what cost? Covered calls offer a straightforward way to turn your stocks into a steady cash flow machine, yet they come with a trade-off that many overlook.
This decades-old strategy has helped countless investors generate extra income in both regular and registered accounts, but before jumping in, you need to understand one thing: increased income comes with a catch.
So, is this strategy **right for you**? By the end of this article, you’ll know whether covered calls align with your investing goals—or if they could cost you more than they’re worth.
Covered Calls 101: The Income Investor’s Side Hustle
A covered call is one of the simplest options strategies out there, yet most retail investors ignore it. Here’s how it works:
- You own a stock and want to generate extra income from it.
- You sell a call option on that stock, agreeing to sell your shares at a certain price (the strike price) if the stock rises above it.
- You collect an upfront cash premium for selling the call option—whether or not the stock actually gets called away.
- If the stock stays below the strike price, you keep the shares and the premium, and you can repeat the process.
- If the stock rises above the strike price, you sell the shares at the agreed-upon price—but still keep the premium.
In short, you get paid to hold stocks, with the trade-off being a cap on your potential gains if the stock soars.
The Upside: Why Investors Love Covered Calls
1. Generate Extra Income
Selling covered calls means you’re getting paid upfront in the form of option premiums. This can provide a steady stream of income on top of any dividends your stocks pay. Some investors use covered calls to boost their cash flow in retirement, while others reinvest the premiums to compound their wealth faster.
2. Cushion Against Market Declines
While covered calls won’t eliminate risk, they offer a small buffer. If your stock declines slightly, the premium you collected reduces the impact. For example, if you sell a call for $2 per share and the stock drops by $2, you’ve essentially broken even instead of taking the loss.
The Downside: What You Sacrifice
1. You Limit Your Gains
If the stock soars past the strike price, you’ll have to sell at that price—leaving potential profits on the table. For example, if you write a covered call with a $50 strike price and the stock shoots up to $70, you’re stuck selling at $50 while someone else enjoys the extra gains.
2. It Won’t Save You in a Crash
Covered calls provide some downside protection, but not much. If a stock tanks, the premium you collected will only offset a fraction of the losses. Unlike buying puts or hedging with other options, covered calls won’t protect you from a major selloff.
Who Should Use Covered Calls?
This strategy is not for everyone—but if your goal is boosting income while still holding stocks, covered calls could be a perfect fit.
Best for investors who prioritize income over maximizing capital gains.
Great for long-term stockholders who want to get paid while waiting for gradual appreciation.
Not ideal for those chasing explosive growth stocks—because covered calls cap your upside.
Coming Up Next: The Best Covered Call ETFs (And How to Pick a Winner)
On Wednesday, we’ll break down two ETFs that use this exact strategy and show you how to know if one is a winner to put in your portfolio or a loser to avoid at all costs.
Want to make sure you don’t miss it?
Subscribe now and get it delivered straight to your inbox.
Disclaimer: This analysis is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Investors should conduct their own due diligence and consult with a financial advisor before making investment decisions.